Will the US military purchase a suborbital point to point delivery capability before 2030?
Will the US military purchase a suborbital point to point delivery capability before 2030?
Mini
6
Ṁ238
2029
53%
chance

Purchase: buy a vehicle outright or contract a private corporation to provide that service on demand. The vehicle does not have to be operational by 2030, as long as the contract is signed this will resolve YES.

Suborbital is here understood to include fractional orbit systems

The vehicle (or its upper stage) should be capable, at the very least, of travelling between anywhere in the US and Japan.

Obviously, the vehicle must have a payload capacity. However, I will not presuppose to judge what this might be. If the US military signs a contract within the spirit of this market that will be enough.

The capability should outcompete existing cargo planes. That means that it needs to maintained in such a way that it can be utilised in under 12 hours from first notice.

Get Ṁ1,000 play money


Sort by:

Just to clarify, this would have to be a contract for an operational service, not a demonstration mission? Also, how would you handle a situation in which a contract is signed before 2030, but the system is still in development and relevant specifications like range and preparation time are not public?

1y

@sesquipedalianThaumaturge specifications not being public doesn't concern me too much because I just can't conceive that they would go for something that fits the spirit of this market but not the criteria. Obviously will have to look at what's actually in front of us to see whether that assumption holds up. I'll just make good faith decisions if it doesn't.

A demonstrator scenario is a bit concerning. If it's clearly for a single mission or demonstrator vehicle that won't qualify, but if it's somewhat unclear (small number of vehicles, slightly speculative language in press releases, clear opportunities to cancel the contract), I'd be inclined to count it. However, this would really depend on the exact situation and I won't hem myself in now with more criteria that might end up impacting my ability to resolve in the spirit of the market.

predicts NO 1y

@JoshuaWilkes I'm mostly wondering about the "under 12 hours from first notice" thing. If it's 2030 and there's a contract for an operational system, but we don't know what the designed lead time before a flight is (or it's something vague like "less than 24 hours"), how would you resolve? Or would you wait until we know how the system performs?

1y

@sesquipedalianThaumaturge if it's something like 'less than 24 hours' or even just a vague adjective like 'rapid deployment' I'd be inclined to resolve YES because there's no real value proposition in that if it doesn't offer a step change over existing cargo jets which could do the task in roughly 24 hours

What is this?

What is Manifold?
Manifold is a social prediction market with real-time odds on wide ranging news such as politics, tech, sports and more!
Participate for free in sweepstakes markets to win sweepcash which can be withdrawn for real money!
Are our predictions accurate?
Yes! Manifold is very well calibrated, with forecasts on average within 4 percentage points of the true probability. Our probabilities are created by users buying and selling shares of a market.
In the 2022 US midterm elections, we outperformed all other prediction market platforms and were in line with FiveThirtyEight’s performance. Many people who don't like trading still use Manifold to get reliable news.
Why should I trade?
Trading contributes to accurate answers of important, real-world questions and helps you stay more accountable as you make predictions.
Trade with S Sweepcash (𝕊) for a chance to win withdrawable cash prizes.
Get started for free! No credit card required.
What are sweepstakes markets?
There are two types of markets on Manifold: play money and sweepstakes.
By default all markets are play money and use mana. These markets allow you to win more mana but do not award any prizes which can be cashed out.
Selected markets will have a sweepstakes toggle. These require sweepcash to participate and allow winners to withdraw any sweepcash won to real money.
As play money and sweepstakes markets are independent of each other, they may have different odds even though they share the same question and comments.
Learn more.