How much time left until drones completely replace soldiers (army, navy and air/space force) in at least one nation?
How much time left until drones completely replace soldiers (army, navy and air/space force) in at least one nation?
➕
Plus
15
Ṁ682
2073
4%
5 years
14%
10 years
17%
20 years
65%
50 years or more

"Completely replace" would mean "there is nobody on the ground, everything is remote". There would still be people remotely overseeing operations. As for how widespread that would be, let us say that this should apply to at least one nation with real combat experience (size does not matter).

Get Ṁ1,000 play money


Sort by:
1y

Can you operationalize the resolution criteria? “Completely replace” is a bit vague.

Does the question resolve once ~virtually all (>99%) of direct operation of military equipment is autonomous or manned remotely? If humans are deployed to combat zones, but they don’t engage in direct combat (in favor of command and control or something), does the question resolve? What if there are still traditionally armed infantry units stationed in combat zones, but they’re used very rarely instead of drones?

What about if there are still people on naval vessels like aircraft carriers, but all weapons systems are automatic?

Does this resolve based on the capabilities of at least one nation, or does it have to be common among many nations? Do small nations with small militaries count? If a nation has a ~completely automated military but isn’t using it in a time of peace, does the question resolve? What about if a nation clearly has the capability not to use soldiers but chooses to use them anyway?

1y

@AdamK "Completely replace" would mean "there is nobody on the ground, everything is remote". There would still be people remotely overseeing operations. As for how widespread that would be, let us say that this should apply to at least one nation with real combat experience (size does not matter).

What is this?

What is Manifold?
Manifold is a social prediction market with real-time odds on wide ranging news such as politics, tech, sports and more!
Participate for free in sweepstakes markets to win sweepcash which can be withdrawn for real money!
Are our predictions accurate?
Yes! Manifold is very well calibrated, with forecasts on average within 4 percentage points of the true probability. Our probabilities are created by users buying and selling shares of a market.
In the 2022 US midterm elections, we outperformed all other prediction market platforms and were in line with FiveThirtyEight’s performance. Many people who don't like trading still use Manifold to get reliable news.
Why should I trade?
Trading contributes to accurate answers of important, real-world questions and helps you stay more accountable as you make predictions.
Trade with S Sweepcash (𝕊) for a chance to win withdrawable cash prizes.
Get started for free! No credit card required.
What are sweepstakes markets?
There are two types of markets on Manifold: play money and sweepstakes.
By default all markets are play money and use mana. These markets allow you to win more mana but do not award any prizes which can be cashed out.
Selected markets will have a sweepstakes toggle. These require sweepcash to participate and allow winners to withdraw any sweepcash won to real money.
As play money and sweepstakes markets are independent of each other, they may have different odds even though they share the same question and comments.
Learn more.