Which teams will make the 2025 MLB Postseason? (Division Series)
➕
Plus
92
Ṁ67k
resolved Oct 11
Resolved
YES
Chicago Cubs
Resolved
YES
Detroit Tigers
Resolved
YES
Los Angeles Dodgers
Resolved
YES
Milwaukee Brewers
Resolved
YES
New York Yankees
Resolved
YES
Philadelphia Phillies
Resolved
YES
Seattle Mariners
Resolved
YES
Toronto Blue Jays
Resolved
NO
Arizona Diamondbacks
Resolved
NO
Atlanta Braves
Resolved
NO
Baltimore Orioles
Resolved
NO
Boston Red Sox
Resolved
NO
Chicago White Sox
Resolved
NO
Cincinnati Reds
Resolved
NO
Cleveland Guardians
Resolved
NO
Colorado Rockies
Resolved
NO
Houston Astros
Resolved
NO
Kansas City Royals
Resolved
NO
Los Angeles Angels
Resolved
NO
Miami Marlins

Which teams will make it to the 2025 MLB Postseason?

Only 8 teams will Resolve YES here, as winning the wild card will not be sufficient for a YES Resolution, teams need to make the Division Series to count.

Note: Regardless if teams move cities during the 2024-2025 offseason, your vote for them will still count.

Also bet on the World Series winner here:

Get Ṁ1,000 play money

🏅 Top traders

#NameTotal profit
1Ṁ1,176
2Ṁ1,125
3Ṁ884
4Ṁ534
5Ṁ364
Sort by:

yooooooo only an 800 mana loss! This exceeds my expectations

@mattyb Resolve please.

sold Ṁ1 Chicago Cubs NO

Oi @mattyb we're done here

@mods creator pinged 8 days ago last active 7 months ago, resolve please.

@ChristopherRandles done. lmk if I made any mistakes

Title doesn't match the fine print... nice, thanks yo 🥳

gosh darned caveats

@Qoiuoiuoiu welp there goes a buncha mana

@Qoiuoiuoiu ah was that you with Yankees at 99%? 🙇 sorry it's like this. You'll still probably win a little mana though

@JTBooth Indeed, misread the description. Ya know, it is what it is though, onto the next market with that tumbles energy fr

bought Ṁ2 Arizona Diamondbacks YES

Hey, rounding off the 99% and 1% teams, this market is expecting 8.13 teams to make the LDS! that's good work

👀 Reds

@JTBooth if they don't beat the Dodgers the 👀 mean nothing

filled a Ṁ20 Cincinnati Reds NO at 12% order

Maybe edit the title to "Which MLB teams will make the 2025 LDS?" I think a lot of traders are not reading the description and incorrectly assuming wildcard teams automatically resolve YES, which is why the market is overvalued as a whole

sold Ṁ100 Answer #cQC06OcIgL NO

Do the Athletics count as Oakland A's for the purposes of this market?

@Tripping Or do they count as "team that does not exist"?

@Tripping the "Oakland As [even if they don't play in Oakland]"? I think that's probably the athletics yes

This market was way too rich in "Yes" - I just took a no position on ~every team and the expected value is still 10 teams making the playoffs.

I turned https://www.mlb.com/news/mlb-power-rankings-inaugural-2025-edition these power rankings into scores from 2 to 8, averaging 5 - white sox at 2, dodgers at 8. I got the schedule from this guy https://www.reddit.com/r/mlb/comments/1e6mrv0/2025_mlb_schedule_spreadsheet/. To simulate a game, I pick randomly from 0 to (team1 + team2), and if the number is < team1, team 1 wins. Did the same for the wild card 5-game series. In case my power rankings were wrong, I also added or subtracted 1 at random, 25% +1 25% -1, before each season. Ran 1000 samples of this to get the probabilities. Partial results:
Dodgers 84%
Yankees 74%
Braves 61%
Phillies 59%
Mets 58%
Astros 57%
Orioles 49%
Brewers 41%

Other takeaways, that the schedule simulation adds to the power ranking:
- The AL west is full of middle-of-the-road teams, the Astros (power level 6) drop from 67% to 57% when I added power ranking randomness, because the Rangers and Mariners are both power level 5.
- The Yankees are punching way above their (power level 7) weight class with 74%. The other three teams on that level are the Braves, Mets and Phillies - and they're all in the same division, which is kind of crazy. Thanks, wild card!

@creator please change the description here to reflect that teams need to make it to the division series. The wild card round is officially part of the postseason.

@DanielTilkin added DS to the title